7 Things I Wish I Knew as a Young Personal Trainer
Coaching Careers
%20(2).png)
I got certified, printed business cards, and thought I was ready. I wasn't. Nobody tells you that the certification is the easy part — it teaches you muscles and reps, not how to actually run a session, read a client, or build a career that doesn't burn you out by year three.
Fifteen-plus years and a gym of my own later, here's what I'd go back and tell the kid who thought knowing the difference between concentric and eccentric contraction meant he knew how to train people.
I came out of certification loaded with information and desperate to prove it. Every session was a lecture — why we were doing this exercise, what muscle it hit, why my method was smarter than what they'd done before. I thought expertise was the product.
It's not. Trust is the product. Expertise is just the price of admission.
The clients who stuck with me for years weren't the ones I impressed with knowledge. They were the ones I showed up for — who felt like I was actually paying attention to their bad night's sleep, their cranky shoulder, their bad day at work before I ever touched their programming. Soft skills aren't the soft version of the job. They're the job. The programming is what you do once someone trusts you enough to let you coach them.
Early on, my "assessment" was a bodyweight squat, a quick chat about goals, and then straight into a program I'd basically already decided on before they walked in. I was pattern-matching clients to templates I liked, not building programs around the person in front of me.
That's backwards, and it's expensive. A real assessment tells you what someone can actually do safely, where they're compensating, what's going to bite you in six weeks if you ignore it now, and — just as important — what actually motivates them to keep showing up. Skip that step and you're not designing a program, you're guessing with extra steps.
I didn't understand this until I'd already hurt a client's shoulder chasing a personal record they never should have been loaded for. You learn fast when you have to make that phone call.
For years I measured my worth in hours trained. More sessions, more money, more proof I was "good." That math has a ceiling, and it's a low one. It also teaches you to think like an hourly employee instead of like someone building something.
What actually moves a career — and a business — is the thinking behind the hour, not the hour itself. Can you assess accurately? Can you design a program that gets someone from where they are to where they want to be without breaking them along the way? Can you make a sales conversation feel like a conversation instead of a pitch? That's what you're actually being paid for, whether you realize it or not. The trainers who figure that out early stop trading time for money and start building something that scales — their reputation, their systems, eventually their own business.
I used to think my job was hype. Get them fired up, yell a little encouragement, high-five through the last rep. That works for about six weeks. Then life happens — a bad month, an injury, a kid gets sick, work gets brutal — and the hype-dependent client disappears, because you never gave them anything to hold onto besides your energy.
Real coaching is building a relationship and a system sturdy enough to survive someone's bad month. It's knowing when to push and when to back off. It's having hard conversations about consistency without shaming anyone. It's execution — showing up with a plan, adjusting it in real time, and holding the standard even when the client doesn't feel like holding it themselves. That's a completely different skill than being enthusiastic, and almost nobody teaches it explicitly. I had to learn it by getting it wrong with real people first.
Early in my career I leaned hard on templates — proven programs, other coaches' systems, stuff I'd read that sounded smart. It felt safe. It also meant I wasn't actually solving the problem in front of me; I was fitting the person to the program instead of the other way around.
The shift happened when I stopped asking "what program should I run" and started asking "what does this specific person's body, history, and goals actually require." That's harder. It takes real assessment skill, real anatomy and biomechanics knowledge, and the confidence to build something from scratch instead of borrowing someone else's answer. It's also the entire difference between a trainer and a coach — and it's the reason clients stay for years instead of months.
I resented sales for a long time. Felt slimy. Felt like it had nothing to do with actually helping people. So I avoided it, undercharged, and wondered why I was exhausted and broke despite a packed schedule.
Sales, done right, isn't manipulation — it's clarity. It's helping someone understand what they actually need and removing the friction between them and getting it. Same with operations: scheduling, systems, follow-up, the boring infrastructure that makes sure nothing falls through the cracks. Skip that stuff and you don't get to avoid business — you just get to do it badly, exhausted, on accident.
I wish someone had told me that understanding sales and ops wasn't selling out on the craft. It's what protects the craft long enough for you to keep practicing it.
I spent a lot of early energy comparing myself to trainers who seemed to have it locked — smooth with clients, confident in their programming, running a full book. I didn't know most of them were faking that confidence too, or that they'd had the same rough first two years I was having.
Competence in this field is built the same way you build it in a client: progressive overload, applied over years, with real feedback along the way. You get better by training people, screwing something up, figuring out why, and not making that mistake again. There's no certification that replaces that rep count. Give yourself the same patience you'd give a beginner client — because that's exactly what you are, for longer than your ego wants to admit.
If I had to boil all of it down: the technical stuff is learnable in a weekend course. The stuff that actually makes you good — how to build trust, how to assess before you prescribe, how to coach instead of hype, how to run this like a business — that's a different education entirely, and most young trainers never get it in a structured way.
That gap is exactly why I built Essential Strength University the way I did. It's the education I wish someone had handed me on day one.
We hire coaches we intend to develop, not bodies to fill a schedule. That means salaried pay instead of scraping commission, a structured path from intern to Level 3, and internal education built into the week — the assessment work, the coaching craft, the business side. Some of our alumni are now working in D1 and pro sports.
If you're early in your career and you want to spend it somewhere that treats coaching as a profession worth teaching properly, take a look at what's open.
— Sam Pitcairn, Founder, Essential Strength
After you submit this form we will be in contact within 24 hrs to set up an appointment to come into our East Liberty location for a performance assessment.
